• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Allan Corfield Architects

Self Build Architects based in Scotland, operating all over the UK.

  • Self Build
    • WHAT IS A SELF BUILD? – EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO KNOW
    • ‘INTRODUCTION TO SELF BUILDING’ EBOOK
    • How to find a Self Build Plot
    • Self Build Construction Methods
    • Financing Your Self Build
    • Site Insurance, Structural Warranty & Legal Expenses
    • Setting Timescales For Your Self Build
    • Designing An Energy Efficient Self Build
    • What Is SIPS Construction?
    • Log Homes
    • Home Design: A Step-By-Step Guide To Designing Your Dream Home
    • SELF BUILD WITH ACA
  • Portfolio
  • Services
    • ONLINE DESIGN CONSULTATION
    • SELF BUILD HOMES WITH AC ARCHITECTS
    • PASSIVE HOUSE DESIGN & CERTIFICATION
    • HOUSE EXTENSIONS
    • VIRTUAL REALITY WITH ACA
    • Self Build Seminars with ACA
    • STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING
    • Quantity Surveying Service with CLPM
  • About
    • ACA BACKGROUND
    • Allan Corfield
    • Meet The Team
    • Careers| Architectural jobs at ACA
    • STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING
  • Self Build Blog
  • Learning Centre
  • Contact
  • Search

Self Build, Zero Carbon and Low Energy Homes – Guest blog by an eco-expert Tim Pullen

Tagged With: Construction Professionals, Guest Blog, low energy homes, Renewables, Self Build, Sustainability, Zero Carbon17/09/2018 By Tim Pullen1 Comment

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn
Self Build, Zero Carbon and Low Energy Homes – Guest blog by an eco-expert Tim Pullen

I have recently been looking at the One Planet Development (OPD) scheme. This is a Welsh Assembly initiative that encourages and allows people to build a house on agricultural land. Of course, the scheme is surrounded by a plethora of restrictions, not least of which is that the land must provide at least 30% of the food consumed by the people living there and meet a further 35% of the inhabitants’ basic needs, either directly or by the sale of surplus produce.

More important is a requirement that the house needs to be “zero carbon” in terms of both its construction and its use.

In case you missed the previous articles of the Eco Series with Tim, here they are:

  • What is the point of building a Passivhaus?
  • What is the point of a sustainable home?
  • Is Passivhaus worth it?
  • The most efficient heating systems for low energy homes?
  • Going off-grid

zero carbon tim pullen

Zero carbon in terms of use is one thing, it is achievable but not easy and we will come to that, but zero carbon in terms of construction is another matter. In the OPD guidance, the issue is fudged, it has to be as it is really difficult to define.

It is an expression, an aspiration perhaps, that has been touted about for a number of years, with no clear idea of what it means or how to achieve it.

When I wrote my first book, 10 years ago, the discussion around zero carbon considered, tongue-in-cheek perhaps, whether the CO2 emissions from cooking breakfast for the lorry driver who delivered the sheep’s wool insulation to the site should be included. Essentially, where do you stop?

A trawl around OPD website shows a predominance of what I like to call “hobbity-houses”. That is, typically round or curved walls, straw-bale, lime render, turf roofs and reclaimed windows and doors. And all of this “locally sourced”. Certainly, this is a step on the road to low carbon, probably a big step, but Zero Carbon? What about the wiring, the pipe work, the glass in the windows, the screws and nails? What about the carbon emissions from the saw that cut the timber, or the lorry that carried it to site (one of the OPD sites used a horse to haul the timber from the road to the site!).

I am not denigrating the aspirations of these people or the effort they are prepared to put into trying to minimise their carbon footprint. It is admirable, enviable even. And there are those among us who are happy living in a hobbity-house. There are also those among us who prefer something more conventional. The problem with the concept of a zero carbon build is that it puts people off even trying.

DOWNLOAD OUR FREE SELF BUILD EBOOK!

Are you considering building your own self-build dream home? If so, download our free ‘introduction to self building’ ebook.

DOWNLOAD

Our reaction to viewing the hobbity-house is that it is all well and good but I am not the sort of person that wants to knit their own window frames from hand-harvested willow twigs. We then turn our back, phone the local builder and settle for the conventional brick and block house with all its environmental implications.

The embodied CO2 for a standard, masonry built 3-bedroom semi is estimated at around 180 tonnes. That same house is likely to emit around 7 or 8 tonnes of CO2 per year (assuming it is heated by gas with mains electricity). With a design life of 60 years, the embodied CO2 is 27% of the total footprint of that house. So knitting your own windows frames may not be quite as daft as first thought.


Choose Self-Build Architect?

One issue: a timber frame house, using locally sourced timber, is said to reduce the embodied CO2 by up to 40%. There are three reasons for this; first, a timber frame house uses far less material – in both volume and weight terms – than a masonry built house, far than energy is required to process timber than to manufacture bricks and blocks. The third is that timber ‘sequesters’ CO2. As the tree was growing it absorbed CO2 as part of its growth process. Harvesting the timber locks the CO2 into the timber, which would otherwise be released as the tree died and decomposed.

If we want to live in a 21st century way with windows, electric lighting, running water and indoor toilets then we have to accept that there things that have embodied CO2 about which there is nothing we can do. But for all the major elements of a build, there are more environmentally sensitive options.

WANT TO STAY UPDATED WITH SELF BUILDING?

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER TO LEARN MORE ABOUT SELF BUILDING

SUBSCRIBE ME!

Case in point: we will need a bit of concrete in the house, even if just for foundations. The perceived wisdom is that the bulk of the embodied CO2 is in the cement. But do the sums (I have) and you will see that it is actually the aggregate that is the bad boy. The need is for a great deal more aggregate than cement in any concrete mix and by the time it is dredged from a gravel pit (or, even worse, from the sea) cleaned, sorted to size, transported to the concrete manufacturer and then to the site, its overall CO2 burden far outweighs that of cement.

As an alternative, the probability is that the local demolition contractor has a concrete muncher that grinds up big lumps of concrete into aggregate-sized pieces. That not only saves the CO2 in new aggregate but also sequesters the CO2 in the original concrete.

The message is, don’t be put off by the hobbity-house image. It is entirely possible to build a contemporary, recto-linear house with a significantly lower carbon footprint than a conventional brick and block house. It just needs thinking about.

zero carbon tim pullen

Zero carbon in use

Again it is a matter of how far to go. The OPD requires that ALL activity is included, travel to and from the house as well as living in it. The argument is that an air source heat pump and PV panels on the roof are great, but if the homeowner flies to the Bahamas three times a year for his holidays then there is still a significant carbon footprint for that individual. The clue is in the name – One Planet – it is about considering the individual’s impact on the planet as a whole.

Which is probably also a step too far for most people but zero carbon from living in the house is achievable. It is all about energy production for both power and heat, and if you are planning to do it there are three things to consider:

1. Plan for a shortfall or an excess – hitting exactly 100% is practically not possible. The energy demands of any house varies through the day, from day to day and through the year. Electricity production is dependent on the weather (usually) and it is practically not possible to marry these two conflicting issues.

2. Energy storage will be needed. This will typically be batteries – electrical batteries, obviously, but there are also heat batteries that could prove useful – but what form those batteries take is another matter. There is the ‘conventional’ battery system, e.g. Tesla Powerwall, amongst many other lithium-ion batteries designed specifically for this purpose. But let’s go back to travel. You might consider an electric car, which has batteries. The idea of plugging the car into the house, not to charge it but to run the house, is being floated in very worthy circles. And thinking about it, it seems to make sense. Charge the car during the day and use it to run the house in the evening. As yet battery technology does not make this a complete answer, but it has potential.

3. Minimising the energy demands of the house and the people in it is the one, the most important, the crucial issue to focus on – for now and the future. Whatever the energy calculation suggest you need at the design stage in 10, 15 years time you will need more. In the 60-odd years that the government has kept the statistics, household energy demands for hot water and power have risen every year. In that same period space heating demand has fallen as a result of more stringent building regulations, but as a house ages it tends to get a bit more leaky and its space heating requirement increases.

zero carbon tim pullen

The issue is that most house designers consider the needs of the owner today, and seldom consider energy demands at all. Low energy, low carbon is as much about looking to the future and actually calculating the demands, rather than just assuming that it is “super insulated so the energy demands will be low”.

Finance

All the above is based on having renewable energy, perhaps a lot of it, and that has a financial implication. But that is not to say that going off-grid is a good idea. Batteries cost money and have a limited lifespan. As things stand today it costs at least as much to store electricity in batteries as it does to buy it from the grid.

The financial argument around a zero or low carbon home is that reduces the running costs and increase the value of the home. The first of these is demonstrably true, the second is more tricky to prove.


AUCHTERARDER

A hobbity-house will be cheap to build as typically it is labour rather than material intensive. The low build cost coming from using friends and relatives to do the work – cheap labour. A more conventional recto-linear low carbon house will cost more to build than a standard, high carbon house. The argument is (and it is a strong one) that the higher cost is an investment against future energy prices.

Again it can be shown that it is cheaper to build and run a low carbon house than an equivalent high carbon one. Whether that translates into a higher sale price a few years down the road is a different question. Estate agents will tell you that there have not been enough examples to set precedents and benchmarks.

For the self-builder designing a low energy, low carbon house is a no-brainer, why would you build anything else? It is merely a matter of degree, how far do you go? It is a matter of personal choice, location and available budget. But perhaps it is also a matter of what the self-builder thinks the future holds.

In case you missed the previous articles of the Eco Series with Tim, here they are:

  • What is the point of building a Passivhaus?
  • What is the point of a sustainable home?
  • Is Passivhaus worth it?
  • The most efficient heating systems for low energy homes?
  • Going off-grid

We would like to thank Tim for sharing his expertise on our blog. If you would like to speak to him about your low energy home project, he will be available for one on one consultation in the Advice Centre at the Homebuilding & Renovating Show in London.

DOWNLOAD OUR FREE SELF BUILD EBOOK!

Are you considering building your own self-build dream home? If so, download our free ‘introduction to self building’ ebook.

DOWNLOAD
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest
  • LinkedIn

Related Posts

  • Hire the Professionals - Design
    Helping Hands: Hiring the Right Professionals for Your Self Build

  • Self Build Plot
    Land Ahoy! - Don't Lose the Self Build Plot

  • Allan Corfield HBR Show
    Self Build Experts: The UK's Top 9

Filed Under: Blog, Have Building Regs, Have Planning, Purchased A Plot, Self Build Design, Thinking About It

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Patrick North says

    27/09/2019 at 8:20 am

    In 2019, low energy home is a must have thing. We all should start considering it. With worsening climate change, low energy home is the least thing we can do to contribute.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Footer

Allan Corfield Architects Ltd |
The North – Lewis House, Unit 213 East Way,
Hillend Industrial Estate, Hillend, Dunfermline, FIFE, KY11 9JF

The South – National Self Build & Renovation Centre
Lydiard Fields, Great Western Way, Swindon SN5 8UB

T 03333 444217 | E info@acarchitects.biz

Type and Press “enter” to Search

 

  • Self Build
  • Portfolio
  • Services
  • About
  • Self Build Blog
  • Learning Centre
  • Contact
  • Search

Copyright © 2018 | Website Design by Jammy Digital

Manage Cookie Consent
To provide the best experiences, we use technologies like cookies to store and/or access device information. Consenting to these technologies will allow us to process data such as browsing behaviour or unique IDs on this site. Not consenting or withdrawing consent, may adversely affect certain features and functions.
Functional Always active
The technical storage or access is strictly necessary for the legitimate purpose of enabling the use of a specific service explicitly requested by the subscriber or user, or for the sole purpose of carrying out the transmission of a communication over an electronic communications network.
Preferences
The technical storage or access is necessary for the legitimate purpose of storing preferences that are not requested by the subscriber or user.
Statistics
The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for statistical purposes. The technical storage or access that is used exclusively for anonymous statistical purposes. Without a subpoena, voluntary compliance on the part of your Internet Service Provider, or additional records from a third party, information stored or retrieved for this purpose alone cannot usually be used to identify you.
Marketing
The technical storage or access is required to create user profiles to send advertising, or to track the user on a website or across several websites for similar marketing purposes.
Manage options Manage services Manage vendors Read more about these purposes
View preferences
{title} {title} {title}